Of all your ideas, how do you choose which one to write first?

It’s a commitment, right? And starting a heftier project always gives me pause.

Some writers are 100% laser-focused on their idea and off they go like some kind of creative super-athlete. But most of us?  We’ve got multiple ideas (guilty as charged), all jostling for attention. And when it comes time to actually start something, the question niggles:

Which idea should I go with? Which one is the best one?

Cue agonizing and decision paralysis.

I think we need to ask a different question.  Like…

Which idea is the best one for NOW?

Truth is, the “best” idea isn’t necessarily the one you should start with. Timing, energy, skill, and plain old life all come into play.

How to Choose the Right Idea (For Right Now)

A few things worth considering when deciding which story to pursue. Some are practical, some instinctive—and all of them matter.

1) What do you realistically have time for?

What else is going on in your life right now? Be honest. Do you have the bandwidth for a novel… or is this a good time for a short story or some flash fiction?

2) Check your energy.

When you think about it - does the idea excite you? Do you get a little rush when you think about it or talk about it? If so - pay attention. That energy is fuel.

3) What matters most right now—momentum or achieving writerly ambition?

Do you crave the satisfaction of finishing something and getting it into the world?  Or do you want to improve your craft? Or are you ready to dive into the big, slightly terrifying idea that might take months or years? All are valid. You just need to know which you need more.

4) Do you need to skill up first?

Some ideas ask more of you. If that’s the case, is there a stepping-stone project that could help you build confidence or technique before tackling the bigger idea?

5) Which idea would you hate to see someone else write?

This is my favourite question. If someone else announced your idea tomorrow, which one would make you feel slightly sick? That’s often the one that matters most.

A Final Tip

Still can’t decide?

Pitch your top ideas to a friend, writing buddy, or colleague. But here’s the trick—don’t focus on their reaction.

Pay attention to your reaction.

Which idea makes you light up when you talk about it? Which one do you find yourself defending, expanding, getting a little bit fired up about?

That’s your clue.

Because not every idea deserves your time and commitment. And choosing the right one—for right now might just be the best way to get you writing.

Want to be a more productive writer? Dive into our brand new book! Check it out here.